- Directed by Charlotte Brändström
- Written by J. D. Payne and Patrick McKay
- November 11, 2026
- Prime Video
- Based on The Lord of the Rings and appendices by J. R. R. Tolkien
- Developed by J. D. Payne and Patrick McKay

Episode Cast
- Galadriel-Morfydd Clark
- Sauron-Charlie Vickers
- Celeborn-Jamie Campbell Bower
- Arondir-Ismael Cruz Cordova as Ismael Cruz Córdova
- Theo-Tyroe Muhafidin
- Elrond-Robert Aramayo
- King Durin IV-Owain Arthur
- Queen Disa-Sophia Nomvete
- High King Gil-galad-Benjamin Walker
- Gandalf-Daniel Weyman
- Marnûkh-Adam Young
- Kemen-Leon Wadham
- Prince Thrain-Eddie Marsan
- Círdan-Ben Daniels
- Narvi-Kevin Eldon
- Gamli-Lee Braithwaite
- Gerda-Amber Mendez-Martin
- Shâgad-Daniel Scott-Smith
- Rat-Faced Orc-Elliot Collins
- Elf-Soldier-Karl James Wilson
- Elven Archer-Richard Hall
- Teenage Southlander-Elliot Morris
- Lossoth Nazgnagôl-Paul Hickey
- Orc Troop-Marc Rodrigues-Bernet
- Lord Celebrimbor-Charles Edwards
- Khamûl-Zubin Varla
- First Gaudrim Leader-Andy Lister as Andrew Lister
- Second Gaudrim Leader-Neil Stoddart
- Third Gaudrim Leader-Richard Leggett
- Elven Attendant-Alex Teager
- Elven Refugee-Amber Doyle
- Elf Son-Hugo Bensberg
- Huge Southlander-Adam Basil
- Royal Númenórean Soldier-Anish Roy
- Brenna-Rachel Payne
- Hilda-Charlotte Keith
- Lord Balbur-Ross Hatt
- Lord Frór-John Cummins
- Lady Freyja-Emily Lloyd-Saini
- Dancers-Roseanna Anderson, Daniel Alwell, Lee Bridgman, Alex Brown, Tom Clark, Yasmin Attree Faloona, Lee Hoy, Grace Jabbari, Lauren Jamieson, Kate Ivory Jordan, Curtisha Kruythoff, Ashley Morgan-Davies, Lea Oroz, Thomas Paynter, Xolisweh as Xolisweh Ana Richards, Brett Sewell, Joshua Smith, Artemis Stamouli, Aisling Tara, Pfion Vince, Stan West, and Oliver Wheeler

I was so hesitant to get into The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season Three when I heard that it was being released in huge chunks. I have no desire to marathon a show that has been weak in large chunks that attempted what this season is attempting-a soft reboot with a time jump. I’m also curious, though if they can salvage anything from the general mess this has been so I do want to take it in so. In that spirit, I’m doing it per episode.
————————————————————————————————-
War rages between the Elves and Sauron as Galadriel remembers a long-lost love while Durin welcomes home his brother.
Marnûkh begins with a recap not only for what happened before but set the situation after the five-year time jump. The problem for the viewer is that it has been nearly two years since Season Two and this does not go nearly deep enough into that lore. This season opener aimed to begin to fix some of the concerns viewers have raised. The problem is it’s hard to remember what those issues were because of the breadth of time between seasons.
With a small fortune at their disposal rather than perhaps lower the budget per episode and extend out the story they open with an information dump that gives way to Sauron (Charlie Vickers) working in a sense. The problem for Sauron here is that the three Elvin rings are holding back his forces as he struggles to create one ring to rule them all.

Scenes like the creation of the Nazgnagôl (NOT the Nazgûl) are over in seconds rather than taking a long period of time to occur like stated elsewhere. I might be more forgiving if it happened over a few episodes yet that was out of the question. It makes what could have been tragic falls. Even the Gaudrim from Rhûn convert quickly.
Then there is the testing of the ring on a random Orc. With all the effects used they were unable to make him bursting into flames feel very supernatural or scary. With the character’s shouting the moment almost became unintended comedy. The evil that should have been conveyed was not.
Vickers does his best to give his lines menace. While he can at times be a little weak in the threatening department, he delivers what he must say with strength and gusto. He takes his time in scenes rather than rush through what he says understanding evil and menace takes time to convey.

Perhaps the strongest scene (or at least the most intriguing moment) is where Sauron is talking to the spirit of Celebrimbor (Charles Edwards). It’s among the strongest acting moments of the episode where Celebrimbor is taunting Sauron and there’s nothing Sauron can do because the guy is not really there! Edwards Gives his character a muted dark glee while Vickers’ stone face communicates controlled rage.
Another strong moment is the all too brief scene between Elrond (Robert Aramayo) and King Durin IV (Owain Arthur). We see their deeper bonds of friendship and all but is all too short. Rather than explore their themes there it decides to spend an ordinate amount of time on a chaotic family scene with Durin’s wife Disa (Sophia Nomvete).
It gets better. We learn Disa slept with Durin’s brother Thráin (Eddie Marsan). Thráin thinks it was something but Disa feels it was no big deal. Bed hopping is such reflexive lazy writing. Mix that with Disa not really caring what she did and this might win worst new subplot of the season. What a soap opera development this is.

I found her lack of guilt over the adultery thing kind of baffling from a narrative perspective. It’s fine if they worked it out and saved their marriage, but how does it look good for one character to stay with another who clearly sees no problem with what they did. At one point writers would’ve tried to include a sense of guilt in the cheating character. It would’ve been expected. She might’ve gotten angry with the other man if he brought it up again. Disa is just annoyed that Thráin is talking to her.
Any momentum built up by the opening is further undone by a romantic elf flashback scene with Galadriel (Morfydd Clark) and Celeborn (Jamie Campbell Bower) because that is the answer to the issues with her character.
That flashback gives way to a battle scene where Galadriel eventually comes into conflict with some human soldiers. For me, the funny part is several of these characters leap into the air. Not jump but leap in a way that is either aided by wires or by one of those little springboard things when you see in BTS footage and it makes it a little comical.

The problem with doing a prequel series containing legacy characters is that there is no drama if they ever put in danger. They may face a serious threat but such characters have plot armor preventing them from being preventing their feet from being in question. Galadriel has a battle with a very evil being but we all know she’s going to be okay. There is clear effort to begin a process of softening the character in this season beginning here. Not much is helped because the writers cannot let go of her swinging a sword over her being spiritually strong.
Much has been made about the orc with the ark as has been as it has been called in the press. Marnûkh (Adam Young) does little in tis episode beyond tease the NEXT episode with his statement of having information that could bring down Sauron like he is going to unleash a devastating political scandal in a forgettable thriller. This could be painful.

While some fat has been trimmed like the harfoots, there is still too much going on here. The show has multiple major characters requiring tending but with ten episodes a season there is not enough time to cover them all. It wants to be complicated but breezes right past that to overcomplicated.
This is clearly an attempt to be better, but in an effort to get better it still has plenty wrong. We’ll see how the season goes but considering how they release the episodes I can’t say I’m going to have much enjoyment for the next couple of days if I make it through.

